Desert homes and urban dwellings need paint that resists dirt. Behr was also commended for its coverage and smooth application and also stood out for its mildew resistance. 6. As one of the painters mentioned, theres no overall consensus on which paint brand is better. Hes studied consumer buying behavior for 10+ years and has managed marketing campaigns for over a dozen Fortune 500 brands. Benjamin Moore Navajo White (947) Vs Behr Navajo White (362) Side By Side Comparison. Regal Select is more forgiving, he said, so you don't have to worry as much about imperfections in the wall if you're a DIYer. In this comparison of Behr vs. Sherwin-Williams, I break down the pros and cons of both brands. Paint is made up of solvents, pigment, additives, and binders. They both have dozens of products and a dizzying amount of colors. In terms of color selection, Behr offers more than 3,000 colors, while Sherwin-Williams has over 1,500. "So to me, it's a matter of what I'm trying to accomplish as to what paint company I'm going to use.". He likes it for high-traffic areas and homes with kids and pets. Cameo White is quite similar to Sherwin-Williams Alabaster, which must be the most popular warm creamy white used by designers everywhere! Pins to Palettes by Behr: If you have a Pinterest account, you can log in through Pins to Palettes to select your favorite boards and pins. The HGTV by Sherwin-Williams line is the only paint across both brands available at Lowes. Sign up for Insider Reviews' weekly newsletter for more buying advice and great deals.You can purchase logo and accolade licensing to this story here.Disclosure: Written and researched by the Insider Reviews team. One downside of Benjamin Moore paint is that it can be more expensive than other brands. The following table shows the VOCs of top Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams paint lines. Sep 6, 2017. The exterior is known for coverage with fewer coats. The binder, pigment, and additives remain. The color depth is stellar thanks to Gennex Color Technology (more on that in the Color section), and the product holds up against scuffs, mildew, and fading. Also, paint with low volume solids is ideal for sprayers since its thinner and sprays on more evenly. The expert at National Lumber Home Finishes, an authorized Benjamin Moore dealer in Massachusetts, told me, Benjamin Moore is one of the best paints on the market. What are the key differences between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams? HGTV Home by Sherwin-Williams Infinity got high marks for its one-coat, streak-free coverage, quick drying time, and ability to adhere to multiple surfaces. You can find a store near you by entering your address into their store locator. That's when pros pick up supplies, and the workers won't have time to answer detailed questions. "What we find is like certain crews will get very used to using one of the types of paints, and they'll lean towards it because they know just without even thinking about it," said Kunz. Behr and Sherwin-Williams both boast a large selection of colors. Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams offer extensive paint lines for interior and exterior jobs, including specialty paints, stains, and primer. Sherwin-Williams doesn't provide a zero-VOC option, though most paints have low VOC content (under 50 g/l). Those remaining elements are the volume solids. This tool uses your input to create a custom color palette. They also feature stains, primers, and specialty paints. For the most part, they all said both have several good product lines backed by massive research-and-development budgets. Volume solids determine coverage and finish. BM is great because they have kept their focus on quality, and not going for discounts, over expanding, etc. Sherwin-Williams also features a special line, HGTV Home by Sherwin-Williams collection, only available at Lowes home improvement stores. Cupboards are also subject to slamming, grease, steam, and other hazards. Paint Colour Review: A Blue-Green Blend - Sherwin Williams Silver Strand. Exterior wood and decks stains are all designed to protect and preserve your exterior wood from the elements. Benjamin Moore Classic Colors Fan Deck: Just in case you want to be even more overwhelmed you can order all of the Benjamin Moore classic paint colors Same goes for Sherwin Williams Paint Deck Paint brushes: I love all of Wooster's paint brushes but this one is hands down my favorite one to use. Upgrading your home's exterior? Available sheens are matte, satin, and flat. Sherwin-Williams Emerald Rain Refresh Exterior Acrylic Latex Paint: A dirt repelling and self-cleaning formula activated by rain or water from a hose. Color consultancy: Sherwin-Williams offers a free, virtual color consultation to homeowners. Get the latest reviews, deals, giveaways, and exclusive content. You have a choice of finishes for each, such as flat, satin, semi-gloss, or high-gloss, with access to all Behr colors for each option. It is worth noting, however, that these ratings and reviews are taken from a small sample size. Most any professional painter who has been in the business for any length of time can tell you that there really isn't a profit margin in paint. Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams: Comparison Chart. But there are few instances where they might prefer one over the other. That brand is followed by Benjamin Moore, Pittsburgh, BEHR, Clark + Kensington and Dutch Boy. Its a paint/primer combo, comes in interior and exterior formulas, and is lauded for its impressive coverage, superior hide, and smooth finish. Its most comparable to Benjamin Moore Aura. Behr only offers preloaded images to visualize colors virtually. We have found that Ben Moore tends to be a little more durable (less chipping and flaking after applying). Use the links below to navigate the comparison: If you only have a minute, heres a quick side-by-side comparison of Behr vs. Sherwin-Williams. Sherwin-Williams offers SuperPaint, Duration Interior, and Cashmere as its mid-range paints. The results are a little sloppier than what you'll get with Benjamin Moore, but you don't need to register. You can order it online, but you must pick it up at a Sherwin-Williams store. Resilience is quick-drying and holds up well in heat and humidity. Like Behr, Sherwin-Williams also groups colors by family. According to several of our team members, Sherwin Williams paint goes on much thicker than Behr paint - often, a single coat of the Sherwin Williams product covered as well as three coats of Behr. Benjamin Moore Ben vs. Regal Select: Whats the Difference? Similar to Behr, Sherwin-Williams also provides color tools: Digital Color Wall: This tool shows you all of the Sherwin-Williams colors at a glance. Learn more. To find out, I spent several months researching and testing each brand. It features built-in leveling technology that makes brush strokes and roller lines vanish. Behr Premium Plus Ultra ($30-$37 per gallon at Home Depot) 5. Sherwin-Williams has been experiencing some paint shortages. Both are higher quality than brands like Valspar and Glidden, but theres not much of a difference between Behr and Sherwin-Williams. The key point that the experts at The Home Depot made clear was that Behr is a much better value because its high-quality paint at half the price of Sherwin-Williams (price varies by paint type, but this is true in many cases). All content on PrudentReviews.com is intended for informational purposes only. Both offer excellent durability, clean-ability, and fade resistance. Benjamin Moore ben is the only budget line of the brand. Benjamin Moore is also a solid coating but not as good with color uniformity. They also found it easy to remove deep stains like coffee and crayon. You can only get Behr paint at The Home Depot stores and on HomeDepot.com. SuperPaint interior is available in flat, satin, velvet, and semi-gloss. That's why we use Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams paint. "It's a waterborne oil base," said Agosta. The low 90's is as close to pure white as I recommend going; any whiter and the colors start looking cool, sterile, and lack complexity. Although the cost varies by paint type and finish, Sherwin-Williams is more expensive than Behr across the board. Get the latest reviews, deals, giveaways, and exclusive content. They know the right nap roller to use everything that they need for that specific type of paint.". Behr vs. Benjamin Moore: Which Paint Is Better? For example, paint with a higher percentage of volume solids will be better at hiding stains than one with a lower percentage. Bottom Line: Which Paint Is Better, Behr or Sherwin-Williams? Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint Interior Acrylic Latex Paint: A paint and primer combo offering a smooth finish and excellent coverage. Thats because it contains extra additives to endure the outdoor elements. Color consultancy: Sherwin-Williams offers a free, virtual color consultation to homeowners. Both offer a range of interior and exterior paints and stains. Use the links below to navigate the comparison: If you only have a minute, heres a quick side-by-side comparison of Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams. They answered my question, and that was it. You can also purchase paint at BenjaminMoore.com, but full-sized paint cans are only available for store pickup. It also changes depending on which side of the Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams debate you're on. Nolan said it's comparable in price and coverage to the Aura line from Benjamin Moore. Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint Interior Acrylic with Air Purifying Technology Paint: A zero VOC formula designed to eliminate odors and purify the air. And for a mid-range, well-rounded, and high-performing paint thats not too expensive, I highly recommend Benjamin Moore Regal Select. Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are two of the top-selling paint brands. Choosing Paint: Sherwin Williams vs. Behr vs. Benjamin Moore vs. Valspar vs. PPG. The painter (with good intentions), tried to match Benjamin Moore Simply White to a Sherwin Williams paint. Both brands have a wide selection of low-VOC paints. With thousands of colors to choose from, picking just one (or a whole palette) can be overwhelming. Both offer excellent coverage, long-lasting durability, and an array of products to handle any paint job. However, they often had limited options, only offering the brand's budget-friendly Ben line. Reply with quote. In general, paint with higher VOCs has a more pungent odor. Behr was called out for its affordability, while Sherwin-Williams was praised for its range of colors and the convenience of the HGTV Home line found at Lowes home improvement store. Kitchen & CookingHome MaintenanceCleaningHome EssentialsBrowse All CategoriesBrowse All Brands, About UsHow We Test ProductsContact UsJobsTerms & ConditionsPrivacy Policy. You can find the volume solids percentage by looking at the product or safety data sheets, but thats a hassle. Sherwin-Williams high-end offerings include Emerald, Latitude Exterior, Duration Exterior, and Pro Classic. Andrew is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Prudent Reviews. It was clear he knew his stuff and understood the ins and outs of paint. Sherwin-Williams A-100 Exterior Acrylic Latex Paint: This value paint provides exceptional and lasting coverage. It fell short in coverage, as one coat will likely not be sufficient for the best results. Note: If a paint line does not offer a specific finish, youll see N/A (not applicable) in that column. It was praised for its durability even in harsh weather conditions. The exterior paint comes in flat, satin, or gloss finishes. Both are by far excellent paints. Its formulated for easy application and cleaning. Email us at reviews@insider.com. We may receive products free of charge from manufacturers to test. If you want to save money, go with Behr. With an LRV of 81, it's right on the edge of white and off-white. Youll find the current discounts and promotional codes onSherwin-Williams Special Offers page. "Color chips are the best way to help narrow down the process," Sue Wadden, director of color marketing at Sherwin-Williams, told Insider. Colors: "I do think that Benjamin Moore offers better colors," said Camper. "So it's like the unholy alliance of oil and water. Sample jars: If you're stuck between a few colors, you can buy small quantities of paint from both companies and test them out. Both brands offer paint with safe VOC levels, but it is still a good practice to paint in well-ventilated areas. Glidden Premium Zero VOC Paint. Thats one reason why many professional painters choose Sherwin-Williams. These are only available in the most popular colors. Paint stores It goes on and finishes smoothly, defeats streaks, and offers strong coverage. So, as you can see the prices between Benjamin Moore's paint lines and Sherwin William's paint lines are pretty comparable, but in general Sherwin Williams is more . Depending on how much paint/supplies you will purchase, Sherwin could probably get you the best pries. Remember that some zero VOC paints gain VOCs when the tint is added. The biggest cost will be the product. Sherwin Williams is also . It's a good choice if you're looking for paint that will last a long time and resist fading. Dunn-Edwards is a Southwest paint and very popular. It's owned by berkshire hathaway. Here's what the experts had to say about some of them. These self-priming paints have low levels of volatile . A gallon is about $76 to $89, and there are interior and exterior formulas. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are solvents that disperse into the air as paint dries. Benjamin Moore vs Behr color match. However, he explained that Benjamin Moore's Aura line seems a little trickier to get just right. Pure White vs Sherwin Williams Creamy (SW 7012) Creamy is exactly what you think, it's creamy. Camper said regardless of a brand's claim that it only needs one coat, you should do a second and prime your walls first. HGTV Home Showcase, $40 a gallon. With Benjamin Moore, sometimes they have a little bit brighter colors, a little bit more colors that are energized," she said. That gives Sherwin-Williams the perception of higher quality, but they claim the actual paint is quite similar. Color samples, visualizers, and consulting, Benjamin Moore Regal Select Matte Base Paint (1 Gallon), Benjamin Moore Aura Eggshell Base Paint (1 Gallon), Benjamin Moore Advance Satin Base Paint (1 Gallon), Benjamin Moore Ultra Spec Scuff-X Eggshell Base Paint (1 Gallon), Sherwin-Williams Duration Home Interior Acrylic Latex Paint (1 Gallon), Sherwin-Williams Emerald Interior Acrylic Latex Paint (1 Gallon), Sherwin-Williams Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel Paint (1 Gallon), Sherwin-Williams Resilience Exterior Acrylic Latex Paint (1 Gallon), Sherwin-Williams Cashmere Interior Acrylic Latex Paint (1 Gallon), Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint Interior Latex with Sanitizing Technology (1 Gallon), The best Champagne, Prosecco, Cava, and other sparkling wines for any budget, 17 best planners for staying organized in 2021, including tips and tricks from experts, Learn more about how our team of experts tests and reviews products at Insider here, Learn more about how we test kitchen products, 7,500+ privately owned stores (some with limited product lines). Benjamin Moore offers three zero-VOC paints, while Sherwin-Williams only has one. There were differing opinions on issues like customer service, suggesting it varies by location. Behr Benjamin Moore Cabot Olympic Sherwin-Williams Thompson's Valspar Other Brands SHARES Recently Tested BEST TIME TO BUY: Learn more Cabot Clear Wood Protector Valspar One-Coat Clear. Good Housekeepings 5-star review of Benjamin Moore Regal Select reveals only upsides, including superior coverage, above-average stain removal, high wear resistance, excellent finish, and low VOCs. We recommend that all customers start their search by first identifying their desired color, and then selecting the product, sheen, size, quantity, and more. Sherwin-Williams Harmony Interior Acrylic Latex Paint: A zero VOC and odor-free formula that is UL GREENGUARD Gold certified. Both Matt Kunz, president of Five Star Painting, and Michael Camper of M&M Precision Painting said Sherwin-Williams has superior color-matching software and mixer. Yet, it is easy to use, offers a smooth finish, and contains zero VOCs in the interior formulas. You forgot the most important part for the homeowner who is doing their own work. Like Benjamin Moore's Aura, Sherwin-Williams Duration is a self-priming paint, said Agosta. It's a soft warm creamy white and is very similar to Alabaster by Sherwin Williams. The company also produces multiple specialty paint options. Behr Ultra Exterior: Good overall score. We recommend Benjamin Moore Advance for trim, Regal Select for walls, SuperHide for ceilings, and Aura for bathrooms since its a moisture-resistant paint., Buckeye House Painting, a contractor in Columbus, Ohio, said, We prefer to use Sherwin-Williams Cashmere or Emerald. You can buy both brands online and pick them up at a local retailer. The exterior paint resists exposure to rain, features leveling technology, and offers excellent color retention and coverage. When Sherwin Williams "matched" my Benjamin Moore, it wasn't a side by side true match. Paint: Sherwin Williams vs Behr Would like to hear some opinions on which one you prefer. Paint contains four main ingredients: water (or solvent), pigment, additives, and a binding agent. But there are some instances where you might prefer one over the other. It is a high-quality brand formulated for hot weather with their LEED certified factory located in Arizona and headquarters in Los Angeles, CA. The chart below shows volume solids across both brands most popular paint lines. Find a SW color you like and go with that. Benjamin Moore offers 400-450ft square coverage, whereas PPG only covers about 400ft square. Use the Benjamin Moore store locator to find the closest location. Materials, including paint, make up about 10% of the total cost, so it makes more sense to save on labor if you can, he said. To be clear, having a low volume of solids does not mean paint is inferior; it just indicates the depth of coverage. Behr Premium Plus Exterior Paint: This value-buy option combines paint and primer for a durable finish that resists moisture, fading, and stains. From Behr to Benjamin Moore, all the major paint brands chose a shade of green for the 2022 Color of the Year. Behr Marquee Exterior Paint: The ultimate Behr paint in terms of durability and coverage; its the brands most expensive and best exterior paint line. The paints we test cover a wide. . Sherwin-Williams Cashmere vs. It was celebrated for its lack of VOCs, quick drying time, and resistance to mold, fading, and stains. Benjamin Moore features multiple mid-priced paints, including Regal Select and Advance. But two of the most popular brands are Benjamin Moore and Behr. Behr uses ten paint color families to group all hues. The interior paint is durable and spatter-resistant. Fortunately, Behr and Sherwin-Williams both provide plenty of low-VOC options. The company offers three baseline interior and exterior paints. They're durable, splatter resistant, easy to spread, and are fast drying. Get up to 10 for free. The best finishes in our paint tests scored 83, the lowest, 43. Water-based alkyd paints cover and dry hard like oil-based paint but are easier to clean and less hazardous, like latex paint. Behr's Sculptor Clay vs. Benjamin Moore's Revere Pewter; Sherwin-Williams Cashmere Paint: Flat vs. Low Lustre It is crafted like a survey to capture your specific needs before offering paint suggestions. Business Insider listed the Best Interior Paints and chose HGTV by Sherwin-Williams Infinity as the Best Paint for a Makeover. . A mid-priced paint from Benjamin Moore, Scuff-X is about $58 a gallon. The HGTV Home by Sherwin Williams collection is available exclusively at Lowes (in-store and online). Fresh Touch Custom Painting & Drywall Finishing, #1 in customer satisfaction with exterior paints and stains, #1 in customer satisfaction with interior paints, Best Interior Paints for Home Improvement Projects, 10 Best Paint Brands for Your Interior Painting Projects, guide to choosing the right Benjamin Moore paint type, solvents may cause adverse health effects, get started with the Personal Color Viewer, Is Benjamin Moore Paint Good? It seems to depend heavily on the managers and employees at individual stores. Sherwin Williams Emerald: Sherwin Williams Emerald is acrylic latex-based interior paint. The paint line offers a variety of sheens and produces a uniform finish. Even though you can also purchase the paint on Sherwin-Williams.com, you have to pick it up at your nearest Sherwin-Williams store. Yes, you get what you pay for. Captivate is the budget choice for the Sherwin-Williams brand. When you buy through our links, Insider may earn an affiliate commission. It was not worth it to me. For example, Benjamin Moores most expensive paint is Aura, and Regal Select is a close second. Although called out for its price, Marquee was celebrated for its hard-to-beat coverage, zero VOCs, and stain resistance. He told me, we use both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore, and they are pretty comparable quality and performance wise across the various lines each manufacturer carries., Truline Painting in San Diego, California, said, We use Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint for the interior. In this comparison of Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams, I share my findings. And both have a solid reputation for delivering excellent coverage and durability. They mentioned that Sherwin-Williams markets its paint to professionals while Behr is more focused on DIYers. In this section, I highlight the Behr and Sherwin-Williams paint options. But remember you are investing in the look and feel of your home for years to come. We also test replacement windows, roofing, siding, and wood stains. Per Gallon Pricing Differences Most paint, with the exception of Behr and some paints sold at major home centers, are expensive at full price. Furthermore, Sherwin-Williams collaborates with other businesses in the home decor vertical, such as Pottery Barn and West Elm, and offers collections inspired by these partnerships. Types of Benjamin Moore Paint: A Guide to Help You Choose. Sherwin-Williams EcoSelect Zero VOC Interior Latex Paint: A zero VOC formula with spatter resistance. So if you see a Valspar color you like, they can easily match it. A lot of Kunz's painters like SuperPaint for hot, sunny areas. The good news is it is quick and easy and helps you keep track of your paint project. The pros also explained what paint you should use when you're doing it yourself or are hiring professionals, the best paint for cabinets, and more. Benjamin Moore describes Simply White as: Simply White has a LRV of 91.7, which is nearly the highest of all the paint colors on this list. In general, more expensive paint lines like Benjamin Moore Aura and Sherwin-Williams Emerald contain a higher percentage of volume solids. One of the most significant differences between Valspar and Benjamin Moore is the price. I chose those states to get a broad, national perspective and avoid regional bias. Now that you know how Behr and Sherwin Williams compare, which brand is best for your painting project? Her home is filled with smart speakers, connected light switches, and smart appliances. It is a premium quality paint from Sherwin Williams, and the outlook is also mesmerizing. You can buy paint swatches and samples online and get them shipped to your home. Greg Agosta, owner of Level 5 Fine Finishes, recommends painting a poster board instead of your wall. Good Housekeeping gave Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint an excellent rating for coverage, stain removal, wear resistance, low VOCs, and a high-quality finish. Aura will prevent mildew and cracking from extreme moisture. If you apply them to your walls, it can take extra prep work and coats to cover them up when you're ready to paint with your final color. Shop and explore your favorite paint brands - we match more than 250,000 colors from Pantone, RAL and all major paint brands, including Benjamin Moore, Sherwin-Williams and more. Decks stain brands differ though drastically in the ingredients, solids, etc. More severe effects may include liver or kidney damage. Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams feature a wide variety of colors for interior and exterior paints. Stauffers Painting, another painting company in Columbus, Ohio, told me, Our company uses both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams, plus we also use PPG as well. Sherwin-Williams offers better coverage, more options, and superior durability its a higher-tier paint. Sherwin-Williams ProMar 200 vs. ProMar 400: Whats the Difference? Benjamin Moore White Dove. Colors may be similar between the brands, but they are not an exact match. The answer is that they offer higher quality finishes, last longer, are easier to apply and are more washable than other brands. Behr received the honor of Best White. These paints are designed for both residential and commercial projects. Check out this in-depth comparison of Benjamin Moore ben vs. Regal Select to learn more. Advance is made for interior doors, trim, and cabinetry and costs around $65 a gallon. "It's a little bit trickier to apply, but it has a much better finish" and is very durable. As youll see, volume solids vary across both brands, individual paint lines, and finishes. While flashing (glossier spots on the wall that look like different paint finishes) tends to happen with higher-sheen paints than with matte or flat paints, Camper said Benjamin Moore's satin seems easier to touch up than the satin line of Sherwin-Williams. Behr does not offer this service. In fact, the EPA banned using the solvent methylene chloride in consumer paint brands. It was praised for its price but fell short on its coverage. Jan 1, 2006. Learn more about all Behr paint on HomeDepot.com. The interior paint is hard to rub off, and the exterior version boasts a limited lifetime warranty.